Skip to content
Dry Eye Center of BrentwoodDry Eye Center of Brentwood

Dry eye

The Drawbacks of Artificial Tears

Artificial tears are the most common answer to dry eye, and they do help. How different drops are used, and why relief from them is often temporary.

Dry Eye Center of BrentwoodUpdated September 23, 20266 min read

Key takeaways

  • Artificial tears add moisture to the surface of the eye, which is genuine relief and worth having.
  • They don’t change why your tear film is failing, so the effect wears off and has to be repeated.
  • Antibiotic, anti-inflammatory and allergy drops are prescribed for different reasons and are not interchangeable.
  • Drops are better thought of as comfort alongside care, rather than as the answer in themselves.

Artificial tears are usually the first thing anyone tries, and often the only thing they are ever offered. It is worth saying plainly that they help. If drops make your day more comfortable, keep using them.

The difficulty is what happens next: the relief runs out, you reach for the bottle again, and after a while you are using them constantly without ever getting further ahead. Here is why that happens.

What they do

Artificial tears add moisture to the surface of the eye. That eases the gritty, burning, foreign-body feeling for a while, and on a windy day or a long flight it can be the difference between bearable and not. As symptom relief, they are reasonable and low-risk.

What they do not do

Artificial tears ease symptoms without addressing whatever is causing them, which is why the relief is often temporary.

Your tears are built in layers, and the outer one is oil, which slows the watery layer beneath from evaporating. Dry eye can involve too little of the watery layer, too little oil, inflammation of the ocular surface, or a combination, and different drops are formulated for different situations.1 Which applies to you is something an examination helps establish.

Prescription drops

Antibiotic, anti-inflammatory and allergy drops are prescribed for different reasons and are not interchangeable with artificial tears or with each other. Whether one is appropriate, and which, is a clinical judgment based on what an examination finds.

Do not stop or change anything you have been prescribed on the strength of a web page. Bring it up at your visit instead.

A few practical things

  • If you are using drops many times a day, mention it at your appointment. How often you need them is useful information about how much oil you are producing.
  • Bring the bottles, or photograph the labels. There are a lot of different formulations and it helps your doctor to see which ones you have tried.
  • The American Academy of Ophthalmology recommends warm compresses alongside regular eyelid cleaning.2 Follow the instructions for whatever you use, and ask your doctor what suits you.

Where drops actually fit

Drops are one part of how dry eye is managed, and for many people a useful one. If your symptoms persist, an examination can help identify what is contributing and what to do about it. What Dr. Rynerson recommends depends on what he finds.

If you have been on drops for years without getting anywhere, that is worth investigating rather than accepting. Your first visit with us in Brentwood is a one-hour consultation and evaluation — request an appointment.

References

  1. Rynerson JM. Dry Eyes. 2nd ed. 2026.
  2. American Academy of Ophthalmology. What Is Blepharitis? EyeSmart. View source

This article is for general education and isn’t a substitute for medical advice. Please talk with your eye doctor about your own symptoms and treatment.

Your first visit

A personal consultation.

Your first visit is a one-hour consultation and evaluation with our team. We welcome patients with or without a physician referral.

We assess your condition and explain what may be causing your symptoms. Depending on what we find, we recommend a course of action and develop a long-term care plan with you.

New patients

Begin with a proper evaluation.

Send a short request and our team will call you to find a time that suits you.